by SteveM » Mon Mar 18, 2013 9:21 am
"Shadows too dark" would be his own personal opinion and taste, and since this is art it is up to the artist to decide how the shadows should look. I believe there is a grain of truth though in what he says. A camera that is adjusted to properly expose the bright scene he was painting will underexpose the shadows, making the picture have dark shows with little or no detail in them. If the photo is taken of a scene with low contrast then it's not a problem. However, with modern cameras and computers it is easy to take several photos at different exposures them combine them to capture all of the detail in the light and dark areas.
If I had been there I would have told him, with a slight lift of my nose, that even a novice art student knows a painting made outside but displayed indoors will not look natural because of the difference in color of the lighting.