by BillParker » Tue Feb 10, 2009 4:50 pm
Looky what I found!
Purple rufe question
Howdy:
I know this has ben asked before since it's in pt.3 of the FAQ, but I cannot access it for some reason so I'll just have to ask it again.
So, what's the deal with this purple Rufe thingie I hear about? Did it exist or not? If so, what color was it and are there any pics? If not, how did this idea come about? I have a 1/32 A6M2 and the idea of a conversion has crossed my mind.
Cheers
Mike Connelley
Re: Purple rufe question *PIC*
In Response To: Purple rufe question (Mike Connelley)
Mike
The "Purple Rufe" myth started, I think, with a 1945 color illustration in John STROUD's "Japanese Aircraft." It was kept alive by such a reference in the IPMS Color Guide to Japanese aircraft camouflage in the early 60's.
In 1966, Rene FRANCILLON made the myth a "fact," which still haunts modellers today, by publishing the color view (see below) rendered by P. Endsleigh CASTLE in Profile Publications No.129.
Perhaps weathering of the original finish down to the red primer coat of the Rufe gave this illusion of "purple" paint on old relics or wreckage?
HTH
Jim Lansdale
Re: Purple rufe question
In Response To: Re: Purple rufe question *PIC* (James F. Lansdale)
This would be a camouflage as effective as a black cat on snow.
Could too much sun and salt do this to a regular paint?
Re: Purple rufe question
In Response To: (Deniz Karacay)
There is some use for a mauve/purple camouflage. First, as the song says, "Purple Mountains' Majesty" comes from the view of distant mountains, as things tend to seem grey-violet in view. The Germans used a lot of violet tones, using a rather bright purple in WWI as part of the camouflage for a while.
Second, purple-reddish tones are a very effective camouflage under conditions of fog and twilight. As these are common conditions in the Aleutians, it was probably viewed as a 'not illogical' camouflage conclusion when the sunken Rufes were recovered and studied.
I still think the only reason that the purple Rufe reports occurred was that it was described on airframes that had been pulled out of several months' soaking in Attu harbor (or which ever island). The surface greyish layers were worn down to translucent, and the primer underneath showed through to give a purple/pink cast. This same effect has been visible on the Nimitz Museum's Val wreckage, where the airframe looks pinkish-mauve, but there are remnant rings of grey at points like rivet heads.
.Mark.
Mountbatten Pink
In Response To: Re: Purple rufe question (Mark L. Shannon)
Experts in optics will tell you that red objects are the last to remain visible as twilight falls - the Purkinje effect (spelling?).
However, when commanding a convoy escort Lord Louis Mountbatten was so impressed by the way one particular liner was difficult to see in such conditions that the insisted on the adoption of a similar shade for units under his command - it was known as Mountbatten Pink, but tended to the lavender in shade. Once he moved on to higher things it disappeared from RN use PDQ.
So the value of Purple for the Rufes in Aleutian conditions should best be described as "debatable". I agree that your other suggestion is much more likely.
Re: Purple rufe question
In Response To: Re: Purple rufe question *PIC* (James F. Lansdale)
I believe you will find that it was a submerged wreck pulled from Attu that led to the mistake.
Re: IPMS "Purple Rufe" Question *PIC*
In Response To: Re: Purple rufe question (Brooks A Rowlett)
Brooks
In 1964, Charles ("Chuck") J. GRAHAM, with the help of his old college roommate, George VROOMAN, produced the IPMS "Color Guide For Japanese Aircraft: 1941-45." Chuck used paints mixed at his home to make color chips of colors thought to be applied on Japanese aircraft. Few were based on relic analysis or actual samples. Orders for the Color Guide were taken by Jay MILLER and the monies were collected for the Dallas Chapter, IPMS under president
Jim SAGE.
Below is the first published drawing of the "Purple Rufe" and a scan of an actual chip (N 9) from the Color Guide. This Color Guide was utilized by Rene FRANCILLON in his missive on Japanese aircraft with no verification as to authenticity from, or credit to, Chuck.
Chuck wrote Jim LONG the following:
"I personally mixed all the colors. I used a Higgin's ink product that was really more of a tempera paint than an ink, but it worked well with an airbrush....
(The purple) 'N 9,' (was) not from a color sample. This is one of the most intriguing colors and it is based only on written descriptions in Koku-Fan and a couple of other sources refer to it as 'wisteria.' As nearly as I could ever determine, it was used only in the Aleutians, if at all." *(Letter: GRAHAM/LONG, 11 December 1995)
FWIW
Jim Lansdale
Credit: "IPMS Color Guide For Japanese Aircraft: 1941-45," Charles J. Graham, 1964, p.4
Re: IPMS "Purple Rufe" Question
In Response To: Re: IPMS "Purple Rufe" Question *PIC* (James F. Lansdale)
Jim -
Having had a wysteria vine in my back yard, its colour is very pale. I really think that this legend of the undead comes from a red brown primed Rufe that has been overcoated with the standard (?) grey. The extreme weathering conditions in the Aleutians may have caused this effect. I vow that I am going to spray some paint chips to see what the effect is. I will then send these chips to my future son-in-law in Anchorage to see if the Alaskan light has any effect.